More Pages: Edmond Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18


Great as a refresher or for a first time moderator
Not bad, BUT I HOPE MORE!

Canal stories that were gripping depictions of that life
folk-sy stories on canal life

Mildly Interesting
A great book!

Has Its UsesA downside: Like most other commentators on Faulkner, Volpe often takes too seriously the seriousness of Faulkner. This is especially apparent in discussions of "Absalom, Absalom!" Unquestionably, it is apocalyptic, tragic, visionary narrative, but it is also supreme farce. Readers need to know that it's OK be bemused by the first chapter and to laugh out loud at the second. Critics have done a grave disservice to Faulkner by representing the novel with such unrelenting sobriety. (Reading Robert Browning's "Caliban Upon Setebos" might be the first step to a cure from much insensitivity to the playfulness of Faulkner's discourse.)
Finally, the page references to Faulkner's novels have not been updated to agree with the current Vintage editions. And the decision to ignore all of the short fiction might have been more palatable had the author not cast aesthetic judgement upon it, in effect "ranking" it beneath the novels. Faulkner's short fiction is not only of the same high order as his long narratives but is inseparable from them.
Tremendously UsefulIn the second section, each novel is given a reading, and while one may not always agree entirely, they almost invariably identify all the major features and events of the novels and are often closer to very careful glossed summaries than they are argumentative. If you've read a novel, these are comprehensive enough to return to you whatever you might have forgotten. If you haven't read a novel, they function very adequately to convey the essentials.
The third section provides detailed chronologies of events for nine novels.
If you're interested in making your own sense of the novels, Volpe's meticulous work will allow you to get down to business more quickly.


Entertaining and educational

Very Inspirational!

romantic book

A pleasure to readOne of the problems with studying the prehistoric is the dry and exceedingly complicated research papers and books. It is impossible for me to understand a period in time without some sort of mental image of real people living in that period. So often writers forget that while *they* have such an understanding, their readers do not. Edmonds addresses the needs of both Neolithic newbie and Neolithic expert in his book by taking the Neolithic and using short fictional pieces to try and bring the objects and places to life. He does so carefully, and it is clear to me that his synthesis of the material has made me understand his argument far more clearly than other methods. The material gains coherence and reality, and it underlines part of his thesis about the nature of 'ritual' and 'mundane' space.
In addition, Edmonds' writing has a remarkable clarity. Often in archaeology, I find myself wading through practically incomprehensible paragraphs. Despite the intimidating title, AGN did not sacrifice plain argument for technical expertise. It was a pleasure to work through AGN's complex theses without first having to struggle through paragraph-long sentences using deliberately specialized terminology.
I am not a specialist in the Neolithic. Others may take umbrage at Edmonds' use of 'created reality' to present his material. I think that the format he chose (short piece followed by argument and presentation of material) is useful because it clearly expresses his assumptions. Anyone who claims to understand a particular society or set of societies and claims not to have imagined those worlds in their heads is fooling herself - or is not the proper person for the job. Part of how we explore and grasp the remains of the past is to imagine, and I really appreciate how AGN brings this process forward. Edmonds makes deliberate use of fiction to reconstruct the past, taking what has been a 'behind the scenes' process and laying it out before the reader.


The reference for angular momentum in quantum mechanics.

An excellent gift to yourself or others!